Erdogan’s Turkey

Turkey is a country of 80m people and 56m adults had the right to vote in Sunday’s general election.  87% of those turned out.  Incumbent President Recep Erdogan, of the Islamic AKP, was re-elected with 52% of the vote, with the main opposition candidate, Muharrem Ince, of the secular centre-left CHP getting 31%. Erdogan’s AKP saw its share of the vote in parliament fall back from 49.5% in the last election of November 2015 to 42.4%. The loss seems to have gone to the ultra-nationalist MHP which won 11.2% and will now form a coalition government with Erdogan’s party.

Erdogan’s rule is now cemented.  He had already got a referendum through to increase sharply the powers of the president.  Now he has won a snap general election just before the oncoming economic crisis facing the country.

Since the failed military coup in 2016, Erdogan has imposed emergency powers in a period of unprecedented repression. The coup aimed at stopping further Islamic rule by Erdogan and restoring the secular state that began with Kemel Ataturk in 1917.  Above all the military wanted to put Turkey back into the fold of international capital and the EU.

With its defeat, Erdogan has moved fast to destroy any further vestiges of opposition and to break with the political interests of international capital, as represented by the EU, the IMF and the UN.  More than 100,000 people have been detained. Tens of billions of assets have been seized and 150,000 people have been purged, losing not only their jobs but their passports (and those of their spouses) and branded national security threats. Often, they lose their housing (tied to government employment) and their pensions. “One elite is being displaced by another: property is changing hands, new cadres are being groomed for the civil service, the universities are being emptied of one class of intellectuals to be replaced by more loyal alternatives, and regime-friendly capital is gaining access to state largesse, including the bounty resulting from asset seizure.”

Under Erdogan, corruption is even more the order of the day (as it is in several of the larger emerging economies like Mexico and Brazil which also have elections this year).

The key reason for the early election was the impending economic crisis in Turkey.  At first sight, the Turkish economy seems to be racing along – with real GDP growth officially at 7% plus.  But this is illusory.  Much of this growth is in unproductive real estate expansion and grandiose government projects.

The profitability of Turkish capital has been in steep decline since the end of the Great Recession.  And economic growth was slowing fast in 2016 at the time of the coup.  But since then Erdogan has engendered a boom mainly in real estate and banking through ultra-low interest rates and public spending.  Foreign investment has come in to finance this unproductive investment.

This credit boom has pushed the inflation rate to double digits.

exposing Turkey to the risks of capital flow reversal at any time.

And that’s the issue ahead.  Rising global interest rates and the growing trade war initiated by US President Trump are going to hit the so-called emerging capitalist economies like Turkey.  The cost of borrowing in foreign currency will rise sharply and foreign investment is likely to reverse.  Turkey has external debt equivalent to 50% of its GDP, and that is rising rapidly.  It must roll over 20% of GDP annually in foreign debt and more than one third falls due within the next 12 months.

Turkey is now near the top of the pile for a debt crisis, along with Argentina (already there), Ukraine and South Africa.

Erdogan makes a ‘populist’ appeal to his domestic support that he is not going to be told what to do by the IMF or the EU. But the result is that the Turkish lira has been diving in the last year as foreign investors get out of Turkey for fear on an impending debt crisis.

Erdogan may have won the election; he may have increased his powers for suppression and autocracy; and he may continue to stick up his finger to international capital. But Turkey’s economy is on (turkey) legs and is vulnerable to a major slump if the global trends on the cost of foreign capital and the end of globalisation intensify.

13 thoughts on “Erdogan’s Turkey

  1. A couple of things you should have added that for the first the HDP has crossed the threshold and wone seat in parliament. Second, you investigate about “secularism” in Turkey and you should have put the word “secular” in inverted commas.

    1. Thanks Nadim, I agree on your ‘secular’ quote. Although I mentioned the HDP, I did not say that they are entering parliament for the first time – the mirror image of the AfD in Germany!

    1. Turkey has a high level of foreign debt in euros and dollars. Up to now the cost of borrowing in foreign currency has been much cheaper than in domestic lira. But the rate of interest on foreign debt is heading upwards and Turkey has a huge ‘rollover’ of debt arising shortly so costs will rise and Turkey’s ability to service them is falling. The fall guy is the currency which is driving up inflation. Erdogan will soon have to face reality or end up like Zimbabwe.

  2. Hail the new Caliph! Long live the neo-Ottoman Empire. With 52% of the vote, socially conservative Sunni Muslims will finally get what they deserve. I hope real estate speculators get their comeuppance as well as their price over value bubble is pricked in the coming months.

  3. Thanks for the astute commentary on the Turkish economy. On Turkish politics, I have a few quibbles.

    I haven’t seen any evidence that the coup attempt was motivated by a desire to return to secularism or “secularism,” if you prefer. Throughout Erdoğan’s time in power there has been a power struggle within the military between Atlanticists and Eurasianists, with the latter being primarily in the secular-nationalist (Kemalist) camp and many of the former aligned with Fethullah Gülen’s movement (so not secular in the traditionally Turkish sense). While the composition and aims of the coup-plotters remains somewhat murky, the best-informed journalism in Turkey (that of Ahmet Şık for instance) holds that elements of the Gülen movement played at least a significant role in the attempted coup. The military was definitely not united behind the plotters; if it had been, the coup would have succeeded.

    Secularism (with or without the scare quotes) is a tricky concept that can take a number of different forms. Pre-AKP Turkish secularism certainly had some illiberal features (most prominently rules on where conservative Muslim women could or could not wear headscarves) but it was not at all a static framework that went unchanged from the Republic’s founding in 1923 to today. The institution by the architects of the 1980 coup of mandatory Sunni religion classes in public school (just to provide one important moment) was the first step toward the current system, which is working to spread religious doctrine across the curriculum.

    Islamist (not strictly = Islamic or Muslim) ideology in today’s Turkey presents a totalizing communitarian interpretation & lived experience of social life (including urban planning, education, even the capture of labor unions) aimed at preventing the emergence of class struggle. It is thus very significant for political economy, even if the strong support for secularism among the educated and well-paid white collar professionals lends credence to the government’s presentation of Sunni conservatism as a populist or even anti-capitalist movement.

      1. Dear Michael,

        “Looks good”, What is that supposed to mean? Please clarify.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: